Nov 26, Other essays that might be of use: The Parable Of The Sadhu The Parable of the Sadhu 1 McCoy is the type of person who is involved with ethics in a way that can benefit the entire group, he rationalizes his decisions by his ethical knowledge. Although yes McCoy did do something wrong.
Analysis from three general approaches. The "Parable of the Sadhu" presents a complex situation which action immediate action was necessary.
Sadhu, an Indian holy man, was discovered naked and barely alive by a group of multicultural mountaineers during their journey.
Each ethnic group did a little to help the Sadhu, but none assumed full responsibility. Their priority was in climbing the mountain rather than carrying Sadhu to the village where other people could help him.
Although the conditions of the trip were so that once the mountaineers went down to the village they might not have been able to come back up, the author of this essay still feels guilty for what was not done for the Sadhu Donaldson There are three general approaches in examining a moral issue and making a decision, those being consequentialism, deontology and virtue ethics.
The essay does not clearly indicate which method was used to assess the situation. In my opinion, the best method would be Kantian deontology. Let us discuss consequentialism first. Consequentialism focuses on consequences as the most important factor in the decision making process Donaldson 3.
For consequentialists the motives of an act are not as important as what comes out of it. Utilitarianism is one of the branches of consequentialism.
Utilitarianism believes in the greatest good for the number Donaldson 3. This method along with egoist consequentialism was probably the one that was used subconsciously by the mountaineers. Leaving the Sadhu was fine because in the end the greater amount of people would have reached their goal and that would have made them happy.
Egoist consequentialists who believe that the greatest good is their own would have done the same, satisfying their desires before helping someone else Donaldson 4. This method, however, is not the best for this situation.
One proving factor is that McCoy still feels guilty about this incident. Therefore, this method did not produce the most ethical response. Virtue ethics, unlike consequentialism, focus on the kind of person each one of us should be. They focus on cultivating certain characteristics and look at every situation in terms of its potential influence on the morale of the person Donaldson This method, although much more helpful than utilitarianism, still produces an unclear response.
On one hand, kindness and compassion are both virtues that would be cultivated if the mountaineers decided to help the Sadhu and carry him to the village. On the other hand, if mountaineers continue their journey virtues such as courage and determination would flourish.
It is difficult to decide which virtues are more important than others and therefore, this method is too ambiguous to be applied to this situation.
Finally, there is deontology, also called non-consequentialism. Deontology, in general, focuses on the motives of the act and the concept of "duty" Camenisch 2.Ethical Analysis of the Parable of the Sadhu Essay Words | 4 Pages Ethical Analysis of the Parable of the Sadhu The Parable of the Sadhu is a story of men climbing the Himalayas that run into a moral dilemma.
His “Parable of the Sadhu,” originally published in the Harvard Business Review in , continues to be widely used in business ethics curricula across the country. He has published 75 magazine articles on the subjects of business ethics or real estate finance.
The Parable of the Sadhu is a story of men climbing the Himalayas that run into a moral dilemma. These are not just any men.
These are groups of men from many different cultural backgrounds. In The parable of the sadhu Bowen H. McCoy recounts an ethical conflict that confronted he and his companion Stephan while on a private mountaineering expedition in the Himalayas.
The ‘Parable of the Sadhu’ discussed how a group hiking up the Himalayan Mountains encountered an ethical dilemma and how their decisions are similar to corporate ethics. Ethics Case: The Parable of the Sadhu. Evaluate the actions of McCoy and Stephen from the perspective of Kolberg's model of moral development.
At what stage did each reason throughout the trek? Do you think there was a bystander effect in how McCoy and the others acted?